It’s been well documented that Fox is likely to get rid of most if not all of the current American Idol judging panel, but here’s some very interesting news — the network is considering a judging line-up of all alums from the show!
According to Vulture’s Josef Adalian, feelers have already gone out to Season 1 champ Kelly Clarkson and Oscar-winner Jennifer Hudson, and Clay Aiken and Adam Lambert have both been mentioned as possibilities.
Adalian is careful to point out that this idea is still just that — an idea. But it certainly is intriguing, not to mention cost effective (I can’t imagine any former contestant, even Clarkson or Hudson, commanding the $17 million Mariah Carey received). Could it work? I’m on the fence. Idol alumni would certainly be able to relate to what the contenders were going through, though their ability to place themselves in the contestants’ shoes may actually inhibit their ability to be honest and critical when necessary. It’s also possible having Idol family members as judges could make the whole proceedings feel more insular and self-referential, distancing the show from the real-world musical landscape that artists and previous judges Mariah Carey, Keith Urban and Nicki Minaj have represented. The most effective impact of this choice might actually be a marketing one — after all, what would more clearly communicate the reality that Idol is the only singing competition that has produced legitimate superstars than to have said superstars be on the judging panel? Ultimately the success or failure of this idea would come down to who gets selected — Grammy winning alumni make one kind of statement; singers who have had a song or two on the charts make a very different one.
So, if this idea does come to fruition, who should make up the new panel? Lots of factors to consider, including representing a variety of musical styles, success in the real world, and choosing performers who are able to both show personality, be knowledgeable about music, and be articulate. Considering Clarkson and Hudson’s real-world success, their involvement would definitely lend this idea credibility, and both ooze personality. Believe it or not, though, I think Adam Lambert would be my first choice for this new, hypothetical panel — he was a brilliant contestant on the show, he’s funny, and he is clearly not afraid to speak his mind. The ability to comment on both vocal skill and performance ability would make him an ideal judge for the show.
Should there be a representative of the country genre? Carrie Underwood has shown some sly humor in her awards show hosting, but I’m not sure she’d be able to cut loose enough to make a good judge. Scotty McCreery is probably too young and too green; same for Lauren Alaina. What about Kellie Pickler? Though she wasn’t the best singer during her time on Idol, as she proved in winning Dancing with the Stars last night, she’s got loads of charm.
Other contestants I’d consider would include Melinda Doolittle, whose insights on Idology with Michael Slezak are quite astute; Constantine Maroulis, who knows from theatricality (but also from creepy stares into the camera); Katharine McPhee, who’s had crossover success into the world of television; and wildcard Fantasia, who would certainly keep the show unpredictable.
When it comes down to it, I think I’d pick Kelly Clarkson, Jennifer Hudson and Adam Lambert. If Kelly said no, I’d go with Kellie Pickler. And if J-Hud declines, I’d sub in Fantasia.
Who would make up your ideal Idol alum panel? Let me know!
READ: The 30 Best American Idol Performances of All Time — A Second Opinion
READ: Ranking the American Idol Winners Based Solely on Their Idol Performances
READ: The Best and Worst of the American Idol Finale